Because the best way to predict performance is to see it in action.

Introduction

Resumes are polished.
Interviews are rehearsed.
References are curated.

So how do you truly know if a candidate can do the job?

Simple: give them a piece of it.

Trial tasks, or job simulations, are one of the most underused yet powerful tools in hiring. They go beyond talking about the work and show you how someone actually thinks and performs in context.

This post will break down:

• What trial tasks are
• Why they work
• How to design them well
• And how to integrate them into your hiring process

What Is a Trial Task?

A trial task is a short, role-relevant assignment that simulates real work the candidate would do in the job.

Think of it as a “test drive”:

• For you: to see how they think, communicate, and problem-solve
• For them: to understand what the job truly involves

Trial tasks can range from:

• Writing a sample email
• Solving a business problem
• Auditing a mock campaign
• Creating a content outline
• Drafting a short proposal

The key is: it should reflect the actual demands of the role.

Why Trial Tasks Work So Well

✅ 1. They Reveal Work Habits, Not Just Work History

Anyone can say they’re detail-oriented or strategic.
A trial task shows you if they actually are.

✅ 2. They Level the Playing Field

Some candidates interview better than others, but trial tasks favor doers, not just talkers.

This gives lesser-known candidates a real chance to shine.

✅ 3. They Reduce Costly Hiring Mistakes

A few hours spent reviewing a task now can save you months of poor performance, frustration, and rehiring later.

✅ 4. They Improve Candidate Experience

Done right, trial tasks actually engage serious candidates, because it shows you care about performance, not just polish.

When to Use a Trial Task

The best time is after initial screening but before the final interview, when you’ve already filtered for core fit, and now need to assess ability.

Use it to:

• Break a tie between strong candidates
• Confirm your top choice
• Uncover red flags before the offer

💡 Pro Tip: Let candidates know up front that a trial task is part of your process. Transparency = trust.

How to Design an Effective Trial Task

1. Keep It Realistic

Use a task that reflects actual work, something small but meaningful.
Avoid puzzles, brainteasers, or overly abstract challenges.

2. Set Clear Expectations

Include:

• A brief
• Deliverables
• Deadline (24–72 hours is reasonable)
• Time expectation (e.g., “this should take 1–2 hours”)

3. Make It Role-Specific

Tailor the task to what success in this job looks like.

Examples:

• For a marketing role: “Write a sample email for our next product launch.”
• For operations: “Map out a basic SOP for processing vendor invoices.”
• For sales: “Draft a follow-up email after a discovery call with [customer scenario].”

4. Be Fair and Ethical

• Avoid using tasks that benefit your company directly without compensation.
• If it’s a longer or high-effort assignment, offer a small honorarium or explain your rationale.
• Always give feedback, even brief pointers help maintain goodwill.

How to Evaluate a Trial Task

Don’t just judge the final product. Look for signs of how they work:

• Clarity – Did they follow instructions and structure the work well?
• Judgment – Did they make thoughtful trade-offs?
• Attention to detail – Were there careless mistakes?
• Problem-solving – Did they ask smart questions or suggest improvements?

You’re not looking for perfection, you’re looking for how they think and whether they can grow into the role.

Final Thought: Hire Based on Evidence, Not Assumptions

Interviews are great.
But they’re still a performance.

Trial tasks bring reality into the room.

They allow you to make hiring decisions based on evidence of potential, not assumptions about past roles, polished resumes, or clever stories.

So the next time you’re unsure who to hire, stop guessing.
Give them a piece of the job, and see who steps up.

‍